With the education now available in the media and online, people are much more aware of narcissistic people. In fact, all people who are abusive show narcissistic tendencies. But not everyone would be classified with a Narcissistic Personality Disorder. The Overt Narcissist is often grandiose in their gestures and sense of self-importance. These are classic narcissists, and they’re the poster child for Narcissistic Personalities. However, the Covert Narcissist is the more damaging and dangerous type. They’re harder to identify and can lure people in by appearing to be the victim. They are more introverted, and the signs of their narcissism can often be mistaken as personality quirks. If you look carefully and honestly, you’ll see that their motivation is primarily controlling others.
This is a short guide on how to recognize and deal with controlling behaviors from a covert narcissist.
Causes of Covert Narcissism:
- Genetics
- Childhood trauma
- Verbal or sexual abuse
Signs of Covert Narcissism
Keep in mind that just because someone exhibits one of these signs, doesn’t automatically mean they’re a covert
narcissist. A covert narcissist may have only a few of these traits, or most of them. It varies. In cases of domestic abuse, many or all of these signs are present.
- Extreme Self-Interest. We all have a certain level of self-interest. But the covert narcissist is only interested in controlling and exerting power over others.
- A Sense of Entitlement to Special Treatment. The narcissist will often perceive insults that didn’t actually happen. Because they believe they deserve special treatment, they’ll act out in controlling ways when they are offended.(1)
- A Constant Need for Admiration. If you do not admire him/her and say so or act like it, you will not be in a narcissist’s circle of friends.
- Self-Serving Humility. They are humble only when it benefits them in some way.
- An Unrealistic Sense of Self-Importance/Secret Grandiosity. Self-importance is not the same as self-esteem. People with covert narcissism actually have a very low self-esteem. They may appear shy, meek, or self-conscious. On the inside, they feel a deep sense that they’re far superior. (2)
- Difficulty Forming Meaningful Relationships. Because of their superiority complex, they find it difficult to be vulnerable with “inferiors”. They find it hard to build meaningful bonds, and refuse accountability for their actions.
- Lack of Empathy. They don’t truly care for others. They care only what they can gain from others. (2)
- Quick-Tempered. They are quick to blame others when things go wrong.
- Never Accepts Blame. Even when the blame obviously belongs to them. Will adopt an attitude of self-righteousness. (“If you’d have listened to me, things wouldn’t have gone wrong.”)
- Avoids Social Events. This is due to a fear of comparing themselves with others and coming up short. So they choose to isolate instead.
- Self-Isolation for Long Time Periods. They isolate because no one can live up to their unrealistic expectations. Also because of their fear of being held accountable for their actions.
Controlling Behaviors Used by the Covert Narcissist
- Monopolizing Conversations. They may dominate the conversation. They may even lose interest when the conversation doesn’t revolve around them.
- They’ll Interrupt. They hijack a conversation or steal the control of the conversation away from somebody else.
- Unnecessary Criticism. When you give them a gift, they may find reasons why the gift isn’t ideal.
- Inject criticism of Others into Conversation. They may find a flaw in anything and any situation.
- Dismissive Remarks. Your opinion, thoughts and feelings do not matter and they will voice this.
- Seemingly Unaffected by Everything/Everyone Else. They may say things like, “Well I don’t care about that anyways”. This is a defense mechanism. Embracing the identity of victimhood, they then feel justified in their own apathetic attitude towards you and your preferences/opinions.
- The Silent Treatment. When something is not going the way they want it to, they implement the Silent Treatment as punishment.
- Stonewalling. When things aren’t going the narcissist’s way, or they perceive a slight against them, they’ll shut down and become emotionally distanced. They may also use isolation as a way to convey the unimportance of your presence.
- Gaslighting. The narcissist denies something ever happened, or insists that you agreed to something you did NOT agree to. Or, they work on convincing you that you are crazy and that things did not happen the way you think they did.
Appropriate Reactions to Controlling Behaviors
If things get hostile or you feel unsafe, leave the situation. Protecting yourself should be your main priority. You can calmly say “I’m here to talk this through once you’ve calmed down”. You could just quietly leave in the middle of their fit/rant. Remember: the narcissists goal is to control you to do what they want.
In Response to Monopolizing Conversations
If you’re in a conversation with them and they change the subject and you weren’t ready to move on, innocently say “You changed the subject!” And then revert back to your original subject. If they try and interrupt a conversation in order to take someone else’s attention from you OR if they jump into a conversation you and someone else are having, say “We’ll finish our conversation and then be right with you.”
In Response to Unnecessary Criticism
If you give the narcissist a gift and they criticize it, say “I chose to give you this gift because it made me think of you. You can choose to accept it or reject it. It’s up to you.” Make it clear that being critical is a choice. You could also ask “Why are you choosing to criticize right now?” If they inject criticism into a conversation, simply say “that’s not what we were talking about”. When they try again, repeat yourself. For a third attempt, shut down the conversation. They can choose to criticize, but you can also choose not to converse with them if they do this.
In Response to Dismissive Remarks
When they say, “I don’t care what people think about me.” Say, “when I find myself saying that, it’s usually not true.” And then drop it.(3) When they dismiss your input on a matter, say “That’s your opinion.” And then drop it. Don’t argue your point.
In Response to The Silent Treatment
Leave.
If they’re sitting there not giving you any kind of acknowledgment, don’t waste your time. Move on to another task, or a conversation with someone who will respond to you.
The narcissist will want to forget about their stonewalling. They’ll want to return to normal without being held accountable. Don’t let them. When they approach you next, or when it seems as though they’ll talk to you, ask if they’re ready to talk about what happened earlier. Say “are you aware that you shut down earlier? That makes me feel like you don’t value my opinions.”
In Response to Gaslighting
When you can, communicate with them in writing. That way when they say “I never agreed to that”, you can confirm that they did agree to that. If they further deny, say “I’m not debating this with you” and walk away.(3)
Things to Keep in Mind
- Don’t expect them to change. You’ll just be disappointed. Focus more on your own reactions to the covert narcissist. Focus on your own heart, and prevent bitterness and resentment from taking root.
- Don’t argue or try to reason with them. There isn’t any logic to be found in their control tactics. It isn’t about logic and reason; it’s about power and control.
- Dwell on positivity. When you’re not around the narcissist, don’t dwell on your frustrations with them. If they learn that you are focusing any thoughts (even negative ones) on them, it fuels their behavior. (2)
- Set boundaries and stick to them. If they try and use controlling behaviors, enforce a consequence. For example, if they criticize you/a gift/your kids/your spouse, respond with these recommendations and take yourself out of the situation. If there aren’t clear negative consequences to their controlling behavior, they’ll never have a reason to stop. (2)
- Recommend treatment. When the time is right, kindly and gently recommend seeing a counselor or therapist. If you believe that someone you love is a Covert Narcissist, it’s important for them to receive an official diagnosis from a health professional. A self-diagnosis, or one from a loved one, is not adequate. (2)
- Lastly, be safe. If tensions escalate and you feel unsafe, remove yourself from the situation. Your safety should be your main priority.
Sources
1. Brazier, Y. (2019, February 19). Types of personality disorder. Medical News Today. https://www.medicalnewstoday.com/articles/192888#dependant_personality_disorder
2. Patterson, E. LPC. ChoosingTherapy.com. (2021, May 20). 8 Signs of a Covert Narcissist & How to Respond. Choosing Therapy. https://www.choosingtherapy.com/covert-narcissist-signs/
3. Hammond, M. C. S. (2016, January 29). How to Handle Controlling People. Psych Central. https://psychcentral.com/pro/exhausted-woman/2016/01/how-to-handle-controlling-people#1
by Annalise Harp
Katie McMurray from Batavia checking in!
Hi Katie McMurray! I’m from Geneva!
I don’t understand how people can use and abuse others for years and still play the victim. They must have some kind of conscious right? or do they really just lack real emotions?
Playing the victim is a very common tactic of most abusers. It takes the attention off of themselves. As long as they are blaming someone else, they don’t have to be concerned that they themselves are the problem. They can also be very convincing, charming and well-liked by other people. We are careful here at ARMS and other people should be careful too. We have had to remove posts here of some who are not truly a victim. With our years of experience and training, we can determine the differences. However, to an average observer or to someone hearing the story for the first time, an abuser commonly protrays themselves as a victim…and are too often believed. :-( Hope that helps.
I wish the Facebook groups would do the same. I had to quit social media all together, those support groups enable more abuse than they heal.
I wish social media, like the Facebook groups out there could do the same.I have quit social media since, the constant reminders and awful people arguing was too much. I met some wonderful people who helped me over the hardest times after discard. But the majority of them should be shut down, they’re like a covert narcissist training camp disguised as empowering.
Oh the Facebook groups are a Den of Covert enablers. Please seek real professional help. Trying to overcome ptsd alone is so much harder if not impossible. Hang in there!
I would have to agree to exercise caution there. You will find many groups/boards on narcissism, as an example. But as you read through, it is all the negative things that narcs do, have done and will “never stop” doing. We find that our survivors stall in their healing if they are overly focused on their partners. We’ve even seen some survivors go backwards who are involved in this “movement”. The best healing comes when we focus on our own selves, that means taking our power back and not renting the abuser anymore space in our head/thoughts, and working on the things we need to work on. Some education is good (recommend Lundy Bancroft’s book) for some good education but then focus on yourself, your healing work you need to do (including positive thoughts/gratitude). Studies show that can be as effective as an anti-depressant and last year, the science world “discovered” that we can retrain those negative pathways in our minds that our abusesr has worked so hard to place there. It CAN be done. But a board/group focused on abusers and all they do wrong will eventually take you backwards, if you are a survivor seeking to heal.
Nothing helps much, seeing all the fakers getting sympathy for what they’re doing is so hard when you’re trying to heal
Yes. But you can’t change them-only yourself. We highly encourage you to get the services that you need for you. That is the most empowering position of all.
It’s mind blowing when you look back on all the lies you believed implicitly over the years. Their whole identity is lies, they need manipulation to play the victim while still having power and control over you the real victim. You’re better off not digging, you’ll make yourself sick trying to figure out what was real and what was part of their twisted games to extort or use you in whatever way they wanted. Just try to understand there’s no figuring it out, some people are just evil and will do whatever it takes to get what they want regardless of the pain and suffering they inflict, they’ll always be the victim in their own minds
All true
I’m finding it very difficult to navigate your site and figure out how to get help and join a group.
We apologize for any difficulty. We do not list group locations in order to keep our ladies safe. We will need you to give us a call M-F, 8-5pm, Pacific Time. We are at 503-846-9284 or 866-262-9284. Hope to hear from you soon!
Wow, I am blown away. Unfortunately, I am the abuser trying to change, and these comments resonate with me. I grew up in a violent home, and although I have never been physical with my wife or children, I certainly have been verbal.. The beautiful, wonderful woman gave me her heart, and I dragged it through the mud.
I never in a billion years imagined I was capable of hurting what I was supposed to be in love with. I was always real good at playing the victim, and in some sense, along the way, I probably was a victim, but trust me I now know I victimized way more than I ever was a victim. I currently am not to happy with myself, and truly want to change. P/S I am from Liverpool
Hi Michael. Recognizing it is half the battle. Good for you! We recommend a couple of books. “Discovering the Mind of a Woman” by Ken Nair. It is at: https://amzn.to/3NDhvE8 and also “Why Do They Do That” by Lundy Bancroft at: https://amzn.to/46xLNkh Consider meeting with an abuse informed coach or counselor. We have a gal, Bonnie, on our list who works with a lot of men and feels a real calling to that. Jane does, as well. Here is that list: https://abuserecovery.org/counseling-coaches/ Praying for you and yours.
I am married to one and I feel trapped knowing that I cannot stay with this person, yet I have children involved and I am paralyzed to the act of divorce at the moment.
Hi Zin, please give us a call when you can. We are at 866-262-9284 and we have important resources for you. You are not alone and many of us have been there. We are open M-F, 8-5 Pacific Time. Praying for you right now. <3
This is wiithout a doubt the best article to completely understand this person I am married to. And this describes him perfectly, The Covert Narcissist.
This article truly has helped me to understand what a Covert Narcissism is, and i understand when you state, “Don’t expect them to change”, we’ve
been married for 53 years.
The examples you have given are so right on with my husband. He tries using reverse phychology on me all the time. I hold my ground always.
Thank you
Thanks for reading, Barbara!
I live with this nightmare everyday and agree that it is never going to change…my partner possesses everyone of the symptoms..it completely paralyzes our relationship…I am subject to constant abusive language and behavior..I have been punched, had drink and other objects thrown at me..I have been left in a city we were visiting with no way home..she then proceeded to drive home without me…no accountability…never says she’s wrong, never apologizes, and isolates her slf in our bedroom for days and locks the door…does not either look nor speak with me….so very harsh…this article is well researched and extremely accurate….this type of companion is the epitome of a living hell!!!
Mark, we hope that you will reach out and get some support for you. Feel free to give us a call if you would like. 503-846-9284
My husband has the majority of these traits. He also feels my family is against him. It’s sad he think my family don’t like him or respect him. I’m not understanding why because they never done anything to him but show him love. With me, he is all of this and even feel I monitor him. I only call to check on him like any other living wife should but he finds that to be a problem. Anytime we have a conversation of something that I feel need to be talked about he always places my daughter in it the mix. I feel he has an underlining hate for my daughter. I watch this even closer.
So very sorry, Constance. We have help for you. Please give us a call at 503-846-9284. M-F, Pacific Time. I am praying for you.
So my wife and I have been struggling, a lot. And as I read this, I can definately apply a lot of these traits to myself, but I can also apply a great deal to her. She has hit me before but at the same time, I feel like I’ve also treated her very poorly as a result….or to get even. So how do I know who needs the help? She says that I’m “Crazy”. I’m already seeing a councilor because of her accusations. Am I right to do so? Is that wrong? How do I fix my marriage when I know I haven’t been perfect, but I also feel that she’s been very difficult as well? It’s never one person, but if both partners are at fault but one of them won’t admit it…. what do you do?
Adam, please give us a call. We do have resources for you. We are open 8-5, M-F pacific time.